Dataset ExplorerReligiousFounded 1955

Church of the Firstborn of the Fullness of Times

41%
Moderate-ControlGroup Dynamics Score
4/10Young's · Kinda Culty
4/10Lifton · Moderately Totalizing
Trajectory
Assessment Summary

The Church of the Firstborn of the Fullness of Times, founded by Joel LeBaron in 1955, is a fundamentalist sect with roots in polygamy, later establishing a presence in northern Mexico. It is characterized by internal factions and a history of schisms. The group's religious beliefs incorporate doctrines such as the Adam-God theory and reincarnation. There is evidence of internecine conflict, with one documented instance of a proposal for peace between factions. The organization and its affiliates have faced allegations and legal actions related to labor violations and child labor. While specific details regarding explicit isolation, private vernacular, or extreme exit costs are not extensively detailed in the provided results, the fragmented nature of the organization and historical accounts of religious communities with similar structures suggest potential for these dynamics. Information on charismatic leadership is tied to its founders and subsequent family leaders, and their teachings on priesthood and dispensations.

Ten Criteria
C1Charismatic Leadership
5/10

Joel LeBaron founded the church, and his grandson continued a branch, indicating a defined leadership role, but the presence of 'competing factions' suggests that the authority is not absolute or universally accepted across the entire organization.

C2Sacred Assumptions
5.7/10

The organization holds specific beliefs like the Adam-God doctrine, reincarnation, and the 'dispensation of the Fullness of Times' where 'all things shall be revealed' and 'men are required to obey all the laws and ordinances,' which are maintained through publications and form a core, non-negotiable understanding of reality.

C3Transcendent Mission
3/10

The term 'Church of the Firstborn' in a broader context refers to receiving the 'fullness and glory of God the Father in the afterlife,' which implies a significant, transcendent goal, but the brief does not detail how this mission specifically demands sacrifice within the LeBaron family's organization.

C4Identity Sublimation
1.3/10

The brief mentions materials related to religious beliefs and a publication replying to the church, but provides no evidence of demands for conformity in identity, appearance, or lifestyle, nor any pressure to sublimate individuality.

C5Information Isolation
4/10

The organization is described as a fundamentalist sect headquartered in northern Mexico, suggesting a degree of geographic and social isolation, and its growth 'significantly before the violent schism' implies a self-contained community, but direct evidence of limiting access to outsiders is not explicitly detailed beyond its sectarian nature.

C6Private Vernacular
2.7/10

Evidence documents theological terminology ('dispensation,' 'Church of the Firstborn,' 'first-born') but these are standard religious/scriptural vocabulary without documented identity-marking, epistemological enclosure, or thought-stopping function; terminology is accessible to engaged outsiders with basic theological orientation.

C7Us-vs-Them Dynamics
3/10

The description of 'competing factions' and a 'circular letter proposing peace' indicates internal divisions, but the brief does not provide evidence of an 'us-versus-them' mentality directed at external groups or non-members, beyond the internal factionalism.

C8Labor Exploitation
6.7/10

The U.S. Department of Labor's actions to collect penalties for child labor violations and a federal court case regarding unpaid minimum wages and overtime under FLSA, along with reports of ordered back wages and reinstatement for employees fired for raising concerns, strongly indicate systematic exploitation of labor.

C9Exit Costs
5.3/10

Evidence documents Reddit discussions describing religious leaders instructing members to 'cut off/block' people who left the church, characterized as 'shunning' and 'cultish'; this establishes documented social exit costs and reputational consequences for departure, but evidence does not establish systematic multi-domain enforcement, spiritual consequences by doctrine, or persistence of costs years after departure.

C10Ends Justify Means
4.3/10

There are allegations of harm being concealed, including sexual abuse, indicating a pattern of harm minimization.

Psychological Totalism · Lifton (C11)
Moderately Totalizing
4/10

The Church of the Firstborn of the Fullness of Times exhibits moderate totalism, with characteristics such as milieu control (regulation of communication and information), mystical manipulation (Adam-God doctrine, reincarnation, and the concept of the 'dispensation of the Fullness of Times'), and demand for purity (obeying all laws and ordinances). The organization also uses special language (e.g., 'Church of the Firstborn') and has a doctrine that prioritizes the 'priesthood'. However, it does not exhibit extreme totalism, as it does not have a strong presence of confession, sacred science, or dispensing of existence.

Methodology & Provenance

Scored under V5.2 of the Organizational Coercion Index dual-metric system. Last revised July 2026. All scores are anchored to publicly documented, verifiable behaviors. Framework criteria derived from Young & Reed, The Culting of America (Otterpine, 2026). Full methodology →

Cite this assessmentOrganizational Coercion Index. “Church of the Firstborn of the Fullness of Times.” Organizational Coercion Index Dataset,V5.2 (July 2026). organizationalcoercionindex.org/org/church-of-the-firstborn-of-the-fullness-of-times. Applying Young & Reed, The Culting of America (Otterpine, 2026).

© 2026 Organizational Coercion Index. Permitted uses: academic citation, journalism, personal research with attribution. Terms of Use →

Political Compass
Political position not yet scored
Criteria Profile
C1C2C3C4C5C6C7C8C9C10
C15
C25.7
C33
C41.3
C54
C62.7
C73
C86.7
C95.3
C104.3